War refers to the usage of violence to achieve a political objective. And if there is no "political settlement" possible, then there is no formal "war"
Are there not multiple instances historically where "War" was waged to capture lands (typically agricultural) and annihilation or enslavement of the local tribe / residents / ruler was just "the way of war"? Modern wars I think fall into your definition but even there US invaded Afghanistan / Iraq and installed puppet governments as opposed to actually "negotiating" with someone. I also think that in non democratic socities, the person in control may not "represent" the people. so "annihilation" changes who you talk to.
I see your point. But, there might be one other reason to continue to negotiate rather than attempt to annihilate - annihilation can grow support for Hamas and keep it alive with new followers. How will the young Gazans who've witnessed this attack respond? I bet by developing a deep kernel of hatred for Israel, which can only be avenged. Annihilation requires removal of all support, including Iran/Hezbollah/etc., which is not feasible, I think.
Are there not multiple instances historically where "War" was waged to capture lands (typically agricultural) and annihilation or enslavement of the local tribe / residents / ruler was just "the way of war"? Modern wars I think fall into your definition but even there US invaded Afghanistan / Iraq and installed puppet governments as opposed to actually "negotiating" with someone. I also think that in non democratic socities, the person in control may not "represent" the people. so "annihilation" changes who you talk to.
Sorry - a bit all over the place!
I see your point. But, there might be one other reason to continue to negotiate rather than attempt to annihilate - annihilation can grow support for Hamas and keep it alive with new followers. How will the young Gazans who've witnessed this attack respond? I bet by developing a deep kernel of hatred for Israel, which can only be avenged. Annihilation requires removal of all support, including Iran/Hezbollah/etc., which is not feasible, I think.